As when I reviewed the second film in 2022, I will be respecting the director's wishes and not provide any major spoilers for this film. And anybody who posted videos of any potential post-credit scenes on YouTube should have more respect for the cast and crew than to spoil the movie for those who haven't seen it. There are some story details that I'll be discussing for the sake of addressing my points with the film, but nothing too revealing about the major events in the film.
In other words; if you've seen the film already, do NOT spoil what happens to anybody. If you do, you're a dick. No two ways about it.
But to also reiterate what I said in my review of the second film (which you can find here, by the way), I have to give major props to director Jeff Fowler, whom I had recently discovered had been involved with this franchise since Shadow The Hedgehog's own game back in 2005. And it's because of that association with the series as a whole that he wanted to do the character justice, even getting Keanu Reeves to do his research into the character so that he gets the role 100% right. And given how misrepresented Shadow has been in more recent entries as an emotionless edge-lord who just wants to fight the blue blur out of a sense of pride, it was arguably more important for this movie to succeed or else it would continue to perpetuate that misnomer about him.
Though to be fair (to be fair~), given that it's currently kicking Disney's ass at the box office as of writing this, it's fair to say that it's doing it's job,
Plot:
Sonic is celebrating his anniversary of being on Earth and living with his new family, including new companions Tails and Knuckles. This peace, however, is interrupted when G.U.N recruits Team Sonic after Shadow is broken out of his 50 year confinement, which in turn forces them to team up with Dr Robotnik and his sidekick/unspoken boyfriend Agent Stone in order to stop him from accomplishing his goals. But with the re-emergence of Robotnik's grandfather Gerald, things may not be what they seem to be for our anthropomorphic heroes.
Pros:
As if I need to bring up Jim Carrey's performance as Ivo Robotnik by this point. He's as zany and manic as ever, and he's able to make me (and various kids/parents in the audience) laugh hysterically throughout the entire time he's on screen. It astounds me that, to this day, he's still able to bring that same energy and it really shines in this performance. But it's especially impressive with how he's able to play both Ivo and Gerald so effectively without it feeling like he's just doing the same performance twice (although there is a funny 4th wall joke about him playing two different roles). He brings the same level of craziness to both roles, but his ability to balance out both simply acts as a reminder that Carrey is capable of doing different characters that aren't just energetic and kooky.
As for Gerald himself, he was a surprisingly good antagonist. I was initially sceptical about his inclusion, as he isn't traditionally portrayed as megalomaniacal and villainous beyond his revenge for how humanity has wronged him; but with how this movie portrays him and the ways that he had been scorned, it actually works to the movies benefit, especially whenever he and Ivo are on screen together. I might do a spoiler version of this review in about a month or so so that I can give further details as to why he works, but I'd rather wait for people to see this film before I do such.
And on the topic of antagonists, this film pretty much got Shadow exactly right. I was worried that they would go the aforementioned route of making him a loner edge-lord who could care less about anything aside from beating Sonic, but this film managed to capture all of the main characteristics of Shadow without straight up flanderizing him. His temperament, his stoicism, his anger at humanity for what was robbed from him, and his friendship with Maria are all portrayed perfectly within the context of the film. And as is expected, Keanu was absolutely perfect for the role; balancing out the deadpan humour and his unbridled anger seamlessly and without feeling overbearing or out of place with the tone of the film. On top of that, his friendship and kinship with Maria before all of the tragedy struck is very heartwarming to watch and helps to set things up for Shadow in the finale.
I feel like this film also does a better job in balancing out the tonal shifts than the previous films. There several moments from the previous where the quips and jokes would interrupt the more serious parts of the story, causing something of a disconnect between the two and not allowing for much in terms of consistency. That, however, seems to have been fixed with this film, and it's all the better for it. When the film needs to be lighthearted and funny, they don't overstay their welcome or force the narrative to be mainly a comedy. And when it's serious, the movie lets those moments linger without feeling the need to make this too depressing for the viewer. And considering what we knew of Shadow from the games and in this film, the darker moments never feel like the writers are trying too hard to make things serious just for the sake of it. This is especially true once they start exploring Shadow's backstory; it's given enough time so that we feel the strong bond between him and Maria, and the overall story beats allow us to feel sorry for Shadow without making him a walking pity party.
There also seems to be more emphasis on the Mobians (is that what their home planet is called in this?) versus the humans in this story, which is a step in the right direction. One of my critiques of the previous film was how there wasn't really a good balance between the plot with Sonic and the plot with the humans, with the two almost feeling like they came from different scripts and hastily put together to give the humans something to do for the 3rd act. While part of that is present in this film, with Tom and Maddie absent until the halfway point, it's still handled much better in this one with how the focus is squarely on Team Sonic and the stuff going on with Shadow without having to cut back to the humans doing something unrelated for the sake of comedy. I never disliked the human characters in the previous films, especially as they are among the better written ones in video game adaptations; but I still appreciated the fact that Team Sonic are the focus characters instead of having to constantly share the screen with the human cast.
And the fact that both Wade and Rachel only make cameo appearances is certainly a plus.
In general, there's also a better use of the films humour. It has just as many jokes and pop cultural references as the previous films, but there's a better balance with actually funny jokes versus random real world gags about the Rock being president. Naturally, aside from Sonic's one-liners in the middle of a fight, most of the character-based humour comes from the Robotnik's and their different types of craziness; Ivo's coming from his ego overtaking what little rationality he has and Gerald's a manifestation of his grief and anger due to what happened to him during the Project: Shadow experiments.
Cons:
Krysten Ritter's character, G.U.N Director Rockwell, is utterly superfluous. She literally could've been replaced by any other no-name random military character and nothing about the plot would've changed. Initially, they seemed to be playing up the same idea of G.U.N as the games; of an organisation that has become corrupt and accepting zero accountability for their actions. And given how they factor into Shadow's story, that seemed to be the direction they were going in. But not long after Tom and Maddie become involved in the plot again, Rockwell just shows up once more before being literally shuffled off the set and never being mentioned again. There's virtually no characterisation to her beyond just a stiff-lipped military type who doesn't trust our protagonists. Which is kind of a shame, as I love the idea of Jessica Jones helping Sonic fight an evil mad scientist.
I suppose it doesn't help that, even if the balance between Team Sonic and the humans is better handled, it also mean that the narrative kind of has to make up something for Tom and Maddie to do once they come back into the swing of things. Again, I have come to like the pair over the course of these movies and aside from some of their dialogue not feeling natural, they make for really fun supporting characters. The problem, however, is that they are kind of forced back into the story and it doesn't feel natural with the way that the plot progresses. They're just kind of brought into the story artificially to accomplish something that I think takes up more of the runtime than is necessary
And as is the constant problem with these films; the pacing still needs some work. It is admittedly better than the previous film, where they couldn't seem to balance out the time between the two plot points of Sonic and the humans. However, as much as the stuff with Shadow is very well written and performed by all the important players in the story, it can kind of breeze right by for those who aren't already familiar with Shadow and how his story is portrayed in the games. And even with that familiarity, I still felt like some aspects kind of speed by (pun not intended) and there isn't enough time to fully take it in before they move onto the next plot point. Who knows, maybe the less-than-two-hour runtime might have affected the presentation to have caused the pacing to suffer.
Conclusion:
While pacing continues to be an issue with these films, that doesn't stop this one in particular being not simply a great Sonic movie, but arguably the best in the trilogy. Obviously, the highlight is how Shadows story was adapted and the tragedy that came about from it; but we're still treated with a respectful adaptation of the Sonic lore, complete with a strong sense of humour, fun characters, a better balance of the comedic and serious moments, and entertaining action scenes. And with the announcement of a 4th film already planned, I'm simply eager to see what they do next with these characters, especially with what was shown in the credits.
Again, please don't spoil it. I'm not saying a word.
Overall rating: 8/10 (great).
And with that, I believe that this will be my last post of the year. I apologise for the lack of activity on this blog; a combination of real-life stuff and inconsistent writer's block is what has prevented me from writing more. Otherwise, I want to wish everybody who reads this a Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, and a Happy New Year. Things may seem grim for the near future in certain parts of the world, but I can promise that things will be better if we just try.
But until next time, because there always will be one; this is Callum Lewis, the Media Hood, signing off.